Epic did a great job making a high performance high quality game playable with suboptimal systems. If you think the gameplay is inconsistent then your computer is walking on it's knees.
Fact number one: I have the system(s) to run the game. I ran the game and was interesting at first, to me and my brother. It happens that the graphics were overdone for an FPS game, so I couldn't nor my bro stay playing much.
So then I tried to understand how to make maps and such, and the Ued makes things harder, plus this inteligent "take an headache by each map" process of making playable custom maps. And some really ass ingame bugs were often there, even with latest patch.
Guess what: the game stayed in my system for 5 days, after that nor me or my brother played it again. Also notice that my brother isn't a FPS active player like me, he likes more RPG styled games online, and he likes good graphics a lot, still when he plays FPS is only UT1 or UT2004, he didn't want to play UT3 anymore, and also notice that the UT3 lovers said to him it was a great game, but he didn't play it anymore for some reason, no?
Then join all the players that say that it sucks and the others that say it owns, make your calculations. If UT3 had own at the beggining mostly in gameplay, I guarantee you that such things as bugs would be excusable and the game would be still alive.
Of course, there will be always UT3 lovers like you, and I respect that. You should do the same when you open a thread like this. People come here and give their honest their opinions, and statistics don't lie.
We got the usual flaming, admins screwing around with the setup, opinions based on hot air, enthusiast being scared away because they don't want to be harassed, shooting the messenger and being generally reckless towards people building up the UT3 society.
Fact number 2: You say you openned this thread for an healthy discussion, for everyone, but you made a poll that is a joke, basically saying that UT3 lovers are right and UT3 dislikers are wrong. You started the screwing yourself by making such non-serious poll like that. I mean, I only see polls like that in the spam sections of any forum, not here.
There are no more reasonable arguments being made by the UT3 dislikers. I want to give the opposition a fair chance by relaxing here on my end.
Fact number 3: You are neglecting facts about UT3, facts that many people here stated as being their reasons for not playing the damn game. If you want indeed promote the game, you should tell the truth about its good spots and bad spots. Currently, you just told some good spots, while some of those good spots aren't entirelly true (as many proved during this thread and other threads), and while you have hidden many bad spots about the game.
So next time, I strongly advice you to show the confirmed bad spots and not claim the game is perfect, because I am sure that will make you look bad for the ones that try the game today and tomorrow, because they will see how good the game is by your beliefs, and this thread will fill up even more with such statements you neglect by saying that no one as solid base, because some of them have and you just ignore them, so who's making unreasonable arguments here?
I admit, it was a provocation, just to get this thread going. It seems it's quickly derailing the intended discussion. Polls can't be altered by users and admins decided to just make matters worse. The point is, there is only one alternative, despite that some voted for option number two.
Fact number 4: Talking about flaming and then saying it was really a provocation, I guess there's no much to say here Oo
Feelings are not opinions. If you don't want to feel any better, at least don't try to take it out on anyone other than yourself.
Fact number 5: You're the one mixing both, since you're the only one talking about good things only about UT3, and neglecting any evidence about bad things about the game.
So in resume, this thread failed, and you failed with it. This kind of discussions could really bring the good things and bad things about UT3, and let players that never played it to have their minds correctly cleared, but by just looking to one side of the coin, you can't judge the other side, and you are doing that and you are indeed keeping new UT3 players from playing the game instead of promoting them to, with those attitudes, contradictions and neglects from you.
Good day, let this thread rest in peace