I don't know about that. if you understand the rule, you have to avoid breaking it because most people who are new to photography won't come to understand it otherwise. the only way to learn it is to apply it every time they shoot.
it doesn't mean you strictly compose every single shot you take within the "rule," but it should be followed in a general sense each time you take a picture. in this way, you learn how to work with it while working around it.
it's a necessary guideline in that it provides people who don't necessarily possess a creative eye with a "trick" they can use to turn their photography from average to compelling.
you don't tell people to break the rule, but you let someone work around it in their own way once they have more experience.
I have never worked with this rule myself, I only found out half a year ago what it really meant.
Does this mean allmost all of my photo's from before that period where suck?
see, I think this is misleading.
some of the greatest painters in history have made use of extremely boring composition.
da Vinci, Van Gogh, Whistler, O'Keefe, etc.
painting is far removed from photography nowadays, so much so that I would advise against copying the compositional style of most artists. it's just a completely different medium that looks for very different techniques when it comes to content and composition.
Painters of history?
Uhm.. yesterday is history?
arent there any painters besides the ones "from history" ?
there are also the painters for the future.. and the painters of history will always have some sort of influences in our futures.
Also you are right
some of the painters used boring compostions, but with so many painters there will always be someone that can inspire you.. doesnt need to be a painter offcourse, any artsy artist will obviously do.
You should spend some time on getting deeper into art.. visit a local museum for instance.
Triangle-composition, Symmetric/asymmetric composition, Horizontal/vertical/diagonal/central composition, geometric shaped composition, ritmic composition, open composition, closed composition, lineperspective, atmoschpheric perspective compostion..
dont only yell "Da vinci" or "Van gogh" just because they are famous.
there have been 10000's of painters all having their own style.
Jackson Pollock, andy Warhol, Michaelangelo (was also an architect), Peter Paul Rubens.. want more?
Jacques-louis David was an awesome portrait-painter, theodore gericault was an awesome triangle-composition based painter.
But even William turner has some amazing inspiring work (
http://images.google.nl/images?q=william turner )
to name a few less known artists..
Menno baars inspires me for child-portraits
http://images.google.nl/images?q=menno baars
Fon Clement has some interesting vision on flora:
http://images.google.nl/images?q=Fon Klement
Caspter Faassen has some interesting portrait work:
http://www.artilijst.nl/kunstenaars/CasperFaassen.htm
And people like Rietveld and Mondriaan can stimulate photographers who like abstract photography.
Want some more modern painters?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Modern_painters
Gene davis had some interesting work that inspired me.
Sure you might not have liked what I showed you,
but there are 1000's of other painters and they are all part of history. (and future)
Even though their compositions might be outdated they are still respected and especially the more artsy fartsy kind of photographer should not only focuss on "rolemodels" and "Inspiration" that are other photographers.
The painters where the first photographers and their vision should not be neglected.
Also understanding different "rules" besides the rule of thirds can always accompany you and help you out when the rule of thirds cannot be used or just does not fit the theme of what you are going for.
Remember your kindergardenteacher or your parents telling you to draw within the lines?
That was the moment your creativity got shoved aside.
Paint frikking outside the lines if you want to.
Do not follow the rules, but only do so if you understand the rules.
"The Style"(de stijl) where a group of painters/artists that wanted to go back before a teacher told them to draw within the lines.
So even not following the rules can be a rule to some artists.