*MORE GENERATIONS SPOILERS AHEAD*
I understand his reasons for wanting to leave the Nexus in the movie, but I don't understand why he didn't try to get out before Picard even arrived like he would in any Star Trek episode.
And I don't understand why Picard didn't just recruit some random thug from the Nexus when all he needed was someone to beat up Soran.
Like Woopie said, time has no meaning in the Nexus, so he could have just picked anyone who had "just arrived" and persuaded them to follow him. Why not pick some alien dude with Dhalsim-arms or at least a Klingon?
What did he need Kirk for?
And how could he get out again? When he wished to have a family he didn't get a family, he got a fake Nexus family. Just like Kirk's gap-jumping-challenge and his wife were fake and "didn't matter". Why and how then was his wish to go back to the planet fulfilled for real?
And if the Nexus just provides you with everything you want and wraps you up in joy, how can other people just stroll into your perfect dream and potentially ruin it? I.e. how did Picard get to Kirk?
Or did he never get to Kirk and the Kirk he saw was just his Nexus-version of Kirk? It would make sense that he only threw a couple of rocks on him then but I highly doubt that's how the plot is supposed to work.
The way I see it it only makes sense to assume that
everything Picard did from the point on from where he got into the Nexus was
in the Nexus. He never left it, he never met Kirk. It's all his personal Nexus-fabrication. But the movie doesn't treat it like that. We are to believe final struggle against Soran is real again.
But if it's real, what was the shallow grave about? If it was to keep the involvement of Kirk a secret, what would Picard have done if Kirk survived? Shoot him in the back? And if it wasn't, why not give the guy a proper space burial?
It's all more inconsistent than it needed to be, imo. Maybe the desperate attempt to get Kirk back in somehow because they didn't trust the new crew to draw in a big enough audience on their own is what broke it. I don't know. I just know that my suspension of disbelief ripped too often, even compared to other Star Trek movies.
First Contact was much better.
Does he do any other kind?
Good point.