Red Orchestra Review

  • Two Factor Authentication is now available on BeyondUnreal Forums. To configure it, visit your Profile and look for the "Two Step Verification" option on the left side. We can send codes via email (may be slower) or you can set up any TOTP Authenticator app on your phone (Authy, Google Authenticator, etc) to deliver codes. It is highly recommended that you configure this to keep your account safe.

Raffi_B

Administrator
Oct 27, 2002
2,001
0
0
USA
Mod N Mod has recently taken a look at Red Orchestra 3.0: Combined Arms, rating it a 9.2 out of 10. Here's a snippet of the review:
Red Orchestra: Combined Arms shows the amazing potential and the bright future of this mod. In the versions before, Red Orchestra was good, but only as good as early releases can get. Combined Arms successfully fleshes out the RO concept by adding vehicles among other various upgrades.
You can read the whole review here.
 

Stryker8

New Member
Jan 26, 2000
4,565
0
0
funny how after all those versions they still talk about 'potential', yet its currently at version 3.0 and apparently people have yet seen it fullfilled its 'potential'
 

SquirrelZero

New Member
Apr 5, 2003
144
0
0
frag-ops.fragwhored.com
I think that was more or less a rhetorical reviewer comment than fact. At least when i read it i treated it as fluff. RO's placement in the MSU contest and decent volume of players (as UT2004 mods go lately) means that they probably reached that potential long ago.
 
Last edited:

GAMESOULjA

Sega Gamer From Na Pali
Sep 23, 2004
65
0
0
39
Na Pali
www.playmoreconsoles.com
i dunno i downloaded the mod and..well...it sucked!

why can't we play as US soldiers?????
plus all that russian lettering on maps and stuff- how are we supposed to understand that?

give us more animations (nice ones) bigger player models and the ability to play as us troops or even brotish forces and maybe THEN we will have a DESCENT mod.
as for now, it just sucks sorry to say :/
good luck "improving" it RO team... :zzz:
 
Last edited:

SquirrelZero

New Member
Apr 5, 2003
144
0
0
frag-ops.fragwhored.com
That was one of the most horrifying reasons to dislike a mod i have ever read. It makes the people who call every modern shooter a CS clone look like einstein. You can't play as US soldiers because their mod emulates the Eastern front of WW2, which up until their release was scarcely touched by most WW2 shooters. Oh yea, all that Russian lettering you refer to, that would be because the map takes place in Russia. Smart ass.

I can understand why you were banned from the moddb forums now, and it's clear that their community wasn't the problem but you instead.
 
Last edited:

GAMESOULjA

Sega Gamer From Na Pali
Sep 23, 2004
65
0
0
39
Na Pali
www.playmoreconsoles.com
um...nobody banned nobody from moddb...and RO sucks despite u defending it.
now zero,i respect you and ur work u done in frag ops so lets just stay out of this,ok?
if you don't like my comments then just say so don't be all woo waa on me k!?
yes i had problems with moddb waaaaaaaay back in the day but im cool now its just thaT SOME PEOPLE THERE AINT COOL WITH THE NEW ME.

so please lets just leave that behind...peace
 

dub

Feb 12, 2002
2,855
0
36
I godda agree with squirrel.

For one, in RO your fighting on the wrong front to see US and british troops. (And imho at least it's a deviation from the norm where it's allies vs. axis - DoD, CoD, TTR, MOH series etc)
Again as squirrel said, don't you think it'd be a touch strange if the russians had english signs? As for the rest of the things you didn't appreciate... well thats you own choice, but it's still a bit silly. :)
 
Last edited:

GAMESOULjA

Sega Gamer From Na Pali
Sep 23, 2004
65
0
0
39
Na Pali
www.playmoreconsoles.com
thanks for taking ur time to comment dub...at leats you understand and aint quick to jump to conclusions.

now that u've explained everything i realize i was just blind and couldn't see the games real intent.
but still,the mod's kinda rough round the edges...


i'd take frag.ops over RO any given time...
to each their own i guess :lol:
 

Caravaggio

Custom User Text goes here.
Oct 2, 2002
450
0
0
US
Visit site
Can't really compare the 2, FO and RO are great mods in their own rights. IMHO both reached their "potential" with the latest releases, both including vehicles coincidently...
 

Caravaggio

Custom User Text goes here.
Oct 2, 2002
450
0
0
US
Visit site
If you didn't care for the last version I don't see that you'll like this one too much, I just wanted to throw my 2cents into the pool. The vehicles can admittadly be frustrating as it takes like an hour just to reload the tank, I still prefer platoon based maps. Though RO does have the large open maps that FO should've had for the war gametype.
 

MachDelta

Haphazard Nobody
Apr 29, 2001
1,517
0
0
41
Canada
Visit site
Caravaggio said:
If you didn't care for the last version I don't see that you'll like this one too much, I just wanted to throw my 2cents into the pool. The vehicles can admittadly be frustrating as it takes like an hour just to reload the tank, I still prefer platoon based maps. Though RO does have the large open maps that FO should've had for the war gametype.

IIRC, it takes 15 seconds (Russian T-34) and 12 seconds (German Panzer IV) respectively, to reload the tanks. There was some debate in the community about these times and as they relate to gameplay (longer reloads mean you have to make your shots count) and reality (veteren crews could reload a tank in under 10 seconds easy). So they might change, especially considering neither vehicle is actually finished.

I agree with your first statement though. If you generally haven't liked RO in the past, then you probably won't feel any different about the latest versions. :)
 

JaFO

bugs are features too ...
Nov 5, 2000
8,408
0
0
pff ... a game without decent bot-support definitely shouldn't get a 9 out of 10 in 'reviews'. So a big 'Ha' at the so called 'tougher' review-policy on that site ...

Don't bother getting this mod if you can't play on-line :
The bots still are as dumb and ignorant as Bush.
 

Caravaggio

Custom User Text goes here.
Oct 2, 2002
450
0
0
US
Visit site
JaFo, your last line is kind of funny since the second I saw you bring up bots I was wondering when you were going to put up a "bot for president!" sig. :)