BRZ finished 4th on
Motor Trend's 2012 Best Cars to Drive, going up against the GT-R, Lambo, Porsche, Shelby, and others. Given that it was by far the slowest of the lot, 4th place is pretty impressive and says a lot about the car.
I have to say, when the final specs of this car were first announce I was rather disappointed. Toyota had been touting it to be the successor of the Supra, so I was expecting a monster under the hood. When I heard it was only 200 hp I wrote it off, but seeing all the reviews on how everything else comes together to make it an absolute fun driving experience I've changed my tune. I would still like to see a few more ponies, though.
If I had to pick, I think I favor the BRZ slightly of the two. I like the front a little better. I wouldn't complain if I had to go with the Scion, though.