i loved it! As a comic geek who has read the series at least 12 times in the last 24 years, i think Zach did it.
i'm buying the dvd the day it comes out. There are a few that i wished were done better (calling the team Crimebusters, Rorshach cleaving Grives rather than giving him a saw to cut his handcuffed arm off [which was the inspiration for the Saw series], Laurie murdering two people, no Nite Owl murder, etc.) but , holy ****, what he did film was awesome. Every scene that Rorschach was in was fantastic. Great movie!
Zach's beginning credits were genius. A-.