What kind of rating sys should be used for the reviews?

[Maxx]

Which one is the best? We let the community decide!

EDIT:
This poll will close on 9th Aug 2005 at 11:38 AM

EDIT 2:
I`ve taken all suggestions I`ve seen in the poll, if I left one out....I`m sorry, but I think the best are covered with the poll

 

[Turret 49]

I voted the star system

 

[SaD]

I voted the star system

Looks like we censored every review at the end , but that´s only my opinion.

Final Score : *** <- Really , looks like censored.

 

[Nines]

Voted 1-10. I think that'll be best 'cause then if you have reviewed an
awesome skin and let's say you don't feel like giving it a 10/10,
so you give it a 9.5/10 instead.
Best system, period.

 

[daloonie]

Voted "1/10" system...

Surely the stars could be off-site images to give it the right feel, I'm sure many of the people at these boards have no problem designing these things.

 

[klasnic]

Voted /10 although it and /100 are actually the same thing

 

[Starry Might]

I voted "1 out of 10, 9/10, ......".

 

[SevenofNine]

I voted for the 1 to 10 system since its ez too use and see for people.

 

[Slaughter]

Star System

We could use something like this

 

[klasnic]

@ Slaughter you were up late

 

[UTGirl]

I think 10 stars are too much and with 5 stars you can`t make an accurate score IMO

Best ratingtypes are 8.5/10 or 85%

 

[CheapAlert]

Edit by mod : . No need to jump in and flame.

btw : All CheapAlert-related things at SkinCity are deleted.

 

[Kantham]

Easy to think. And clean response.

One of ten.

 

[CheapAlert]

Edit by mod : . No need to jump in and flame.

btw : All CheapAlert-related things at SkinCity are deleted.

the hell? If you want to play drama back-stab over a little joke (it wasn't even directed towards anyone but the rating system) then fine, don't expect another model from me submitted to your site anymore. When you delete a forum post, that's cool, but when you have to delete my models over it - that's going TOO FAR.

Anyhow, the joke, replicated:

Looks like we censored every review at the end , but that´s only my opinion.

Final Score : *** <- Really , looks like censored.

Final Score : ass - That's too bad, try again next time so you can recieve a rating of DAMN or if your effort is skyscraping, maybe you'll earn the BITCH score!

 

[SaD]

the hell? If you want to play drama back-stab over a little joke (it wasn't even directed towards anyone but the rating system) then fine, don't expect another model from me submitted to your site anymore. When you delete a forum post, that's cool, but when you have to delete my models over it - that's going TOO FAR.

Ok , if I misunderstood it , then sorry , but I aimed it at your last posts at the board month ago and saw not the joke. I sent you a pm after your last post month ago , you never replied .So , what should I think by reading your post after month of inactivity ?

fine, i best stay away from skincity then since it'll be a yiff yiff center, goodbye.

I shall not participate on the site or the forums again.

What´s the problem with deleting your model ? You told us it´s best to stay away from the yiff yiff center.

 

[Curve[UK]]

uh oh

 

[The Helios]

Looks like we censored every review at the end , but that´s only my opinion.

Final Score : *** <- Really , looks like censored.

I imagine this skin was: ************* One starts thinking the skin is terrible XD

I voted for the 1-100 rank system...

 

[klasnic]

@ CheapAlert I think you've only yourself to blame. I saw the post earlier but it made no sense to me as it wasn't exactly in plain English. I guessed it was rude in some way by the wording but there are forum rules which everybody has to go by

Etiquette I think it's called.

[Back To Topic]

 

[JohnnySix]

I think it's a little bit of an overreation to delete all Cheapy's stuff.

Anyone who argues gets their stuff deleted? That's not very mature.

I refrain from making a comment about -1 score for all the lazy recolour/clan tag whores who upload their crap and diminish the attention REAL skinners get.

 

[Turret 49]

Final Score : ass - That's too bad, try again next time so you can recieve a rating of DAMN or if your effort is skyscraping, maybe you'll earn the BITCH score!

Bit of a late input but I read the joke before it had been deleted, and I had a good chuckle from it and carried on. I had no idea this would happen.