Bioshock wasn't trying to be System Shock 2, though. I can't see why that would affect your ability to like it.
I never said it was trying to be system shock 2 but perhaps if it was I would have liked bioshock more. Its not that I hate it I just didnt think it was up there with the likes of deus ex or system shock 2.
Im just not a fan of long drawn out scripted sequences and you'll hear me say the same thing in regards to alot of games like halflife 2 for eg. Bioshock did bring some impressive things to the table in terms of dynamics and interaction but I still believe more can be done to breath life into game worlds.
This is my point though, Im not going to go around lying about what I think about it just so the developers feel better. Maybe Im being alittle hard on em but honestly if I settled for second best all the time then Id miss out on those truly outstanding games that break molds, it also wouldnt leave much for the developers to aim for next time.
See games like deus ex, system shock 2 and halflife came from nowhere and hit big. Now days you get pre-hype hype, the pre-hype, the hype, the launch hype, the post-launch hype etc now thats not sayin those games arnt good but on a whole I find them, especially the sequels, to be mediocre at best. Its not nostalgia talkin either, its just words from a gamer whos been around awhile, so while I appreciate what they are trying to do with bringin a sequel to a much loved IP back sometimes they just completely **** it up or change the target audience so much they lose touch with the original audience.
Its certainly not limited to the games industry though, one thing I find is stuff I watched as a kid gets remade but its aimed at the kids of today so I appreciate it less because my needs have changed since back in the day.
Looking at a Dues Ex 3, I hope they aim at fans of the original more and try to think what those fans would like about the gameplay they are workin on now. Then they can use that and work it in with things they'll use to target the new audience, I do believe that in targeting the original audience of deus ex and their needs now they'll inherently get new players in