Scoring Schema / Template / Welcome Thread

SaD · Jul 29, 2005

Welcome to our Review-section.

A little note from me .

Please be civil .If you review a first attempt of skinning , don´t be so harsh.
Constructive critic is way better.
Try to give your Review a scheme , like MäxX did.

Have fun reading or writing some reviews.

Edit:
Please don´t fill the reviews with spam.We like to have open review-threads, so everyone can vote.
Spam/Offtopic will be deleted immediatly .

klasnic · Aug 1, 2005

Review Template

Hey all I've just gone by some of the reviews here (and the way they're laid out), so have thrown together this template (of sorts) for general use...

As a heading if we could use e.g., UT2004 - MODEL/SKIN - GAME MODEL (if applicable) Hide - FireDrake v1.0

Skin/Model Name:
UT(99/2k3/2k4):
System Requirements: (if applicable)
Author(s): Add Homepage / SkinCity Author Link
Download: Add SkinCity Link If Possible

Screenshot:

Model: (Existing Game/Modified Game/Original)
Animation: (does it use default animations or new - if applicable)
Voice: (does it come with a custom voice - where applicable)
Other: (for anything not mentioned above e.g., species, karma, customization of any sort)

Support (SP/MP/Both):
Support (Team Colours) (None/2/4):
Known Issues:
Additional Info (if applicable):

REVIEW

[Opening comments here]

The Good:

[Good parts here]

The Bad:

[Not-so-good parts here]

The Bottom Line:

[Final comments and recommendation(s) here]

TOTAL SCORE (0-10/10 or 0-100/100%)

-----

[EDIT#1] May edit this as we go along and think of new things

[EDIT#2] Added a custom animation field, etc.
[EDIT#3] Changed the body of the review to Starry Might's style.

klasnic · Aug 4, 2005

Review Scoring Schema - Welcome Thread

The reviews are scored like this (thanks UTGirl);

0 - One Of The Worst Ever
1 - Serious Data Crap
2 - Bad Quality
3 - There's Better
4 - Some People Might Like It
5 - Average
6 - Good (but not a keeper)
7 - Very Good (definitely a keeper)
8 - Excellent (you'll use this for a long time to come)
9 - Perfect (SaDaGe!!)
10 - H0LY SH1T!!

Any changes necessary? Post in discussion thread please :2thumb:

daloonie · Aug 6, 2005

A "source code" for this template could be easy to swing around so I'll take the oppertunity to post it here. This will in some way help reviewers a bit since they only have to copy paste this and fill in the blanks.

Code:

[b]Skin/Model Name:[/b*]
[b]UT(99/2k3/2k4):[/b*]
[b]System Requirements:[/b*] 
[b]Author(s):[/b*]
[b]Download:[/b*][url][/url*]

[b]Screenshot:[/b*][img=][url][/url*][/img*] or [screenshot][/screenshot*] or [img][/img*]

[b]Model:[/b*]
[b]Animation:[/b*]
[b]Voice:[/b*]
[b]Other:[/b*]

[b]Support (SP/MP/Both):[/b*]
[b]Support (Team Colours) (None/2/4):[/b*]
[b]Known Issues:[/b*]
[b]Additional Info (if applicable):[/b*]

[b]REVIEW[/b*]

[Opening comments here]

The Good:

[Good parts here]

The Bad:

[Not-so-good parts here]

The Bottom Line:

[Final comments and recommendation(s) here]

[b]TOTAL SCORE[/b*] (0-10/10 or 0-100/100%)

Just remove the *'s and fill it out. Simple as that

EDIT:: I cleaned out this thread to keep it clean. Every suggestion can be posted and after consideration/and action taken it will initially be deleted to keep it as clean as possible.

Now remember to post a poll with it. So people can judge the skin themselves to get a broader spectrum of oppinions.
If you forget it contact a moderator and we can call it a "MäxX". We'll delete it so you can repost it with a poll. ASAP.

Search

Search

Scoring Schema / Template / Welcome Thread

SaD

Skincollecting Fanatic

klasnic

ra ra rat Putin!

klasnic

ra ra rat Putin!

daloonie

sex boobs nude