Review Discussion

[Slaughter]

I don´t think so...

You´re rating the skin.
The Bio (if there´s one) scores Points for beeing there not what it´s about(it´s different if the only thing the bio contains is something like "I made this skin!Pay respect and transfer money to my paypal account loolol" of course ).

[klasnic]

Originally Posted by Starry Might

I love the "Release-Queue" topic, SaD.

I'm gonna snag "Caige" as soon as he's mirrored (no need for me to wait clean 'till the 14th ). I'd like to review him, but since I'm the one who wrote his Bio, would that be a conflict of interest?

Not unless you say the bio's great No, seriously there's no problem with you reviewing him

[Starry Might]

Originally Posted by SaD

mirrored .

Awesome! I'll download him tonight and check him out in-game tomorrow.

Originally Posted by TheSlaughter

I don´t think so...

You´re rating the skin.
The Bio (if there´s one) scores Points for beeing there not what it´s about(it´s different if the only thing the bio contains is something like "I made this skin!Pay respect and transfer money to my paypal account loolol" of course ).

Don't worry, you'll NEVER see me make a Bio like THAT.

Originally Posted by klasnic

Not unless you say the bio's great No, seriously there's no problem with you reviewing him

Thanks. I won't count the Bio for my score, though.

[Slaughter]

I wasn´t referring to you...i´ve downloaded a skin once that had something similiar as bio.

[MäxX]

Originally Posted by SaD

No idea .I think I list all scores then .

list all and make an average score

*lol* at posts 107-110

[UTGirl]

Originally Posted by TheSlaughter

...The Bio (if there´s one) scores Points for beeing there not what it´s about(it´s different if the only thing the bio contains is something like "I made this skin!Pay respect and transfer money to my paypal account loolol" of course ).

The bio shouldn`t affect the score too much, but for a 10 point score (will any skin ever reach that?) there should be a good bio too

[MäxX]

*agreeswithbio*

I`ll go for Svetlana

My 2 actual reviews are a little bit "short", but there wasn`t more to say

EDIT:
@klas: and this time no poll has been left out, and also the sig was removed with first attempt okok, a small other error was there (thx tur) but I`m still improving.
To be honest, really good skinage makes me sooo excited I can`t think of any polls, I just want to release the review, i cant`wait, it`s.....

*takesicecubestocalmdown*
*brrr*
*drinksteatowarmup*

ähm, where had i stopped? But bets can be taken for the next MPF (MäxX Poll Forget)

[Slaughter]

We shouldn´t stop reviewing older skins...i might give this a shot myself with a few of my favs

[MäxX]

Originally Posted by TheSlaughter

We shouldn´t stop reviewing older skins...i might give this a shot myself with a few of my favs

There are still some older skins I also want to review

EDIT:

Originally Posted by Electrolyte in Yelena-Review

I think MäxX should become one of the main reviewers for the site

[SaD]

Looking at the masses of reviews you wrote , there is something like main-reviewer in the air .

[Starry Might]

Originally Posted by TheSlaughter

I wasn´t referring to you...i´ve downloaded a skin once that had something similiar as bio.

I knew that you weren't referring to me in that particular post.

P.S. - I like your banner!

[klasnic]

Originally Posted by SaD

Looking at the masses of reviews you wrote , there is something like main-reviewer in the air .

Let us hope it doesn't slow down his skinning any more

[EDIT] or it'll be build time 2 years

[MäxX]

Originally Posted by klasnic

Let us hope it doesn't slow down his skinning any more

[EDIT] or it'll be build time 2 years

*lol* you`re right, currently I´m really a little bit busy but progress will come....before 2007

[Slaughter]

My first Review is up...W007

[MäxX]

Originally Posted by TheSlaughter

My first Review is up...W007

A nice review but a poll would be great

I never have d/l that skin, I thought the same thing you did....well seems like I have to check it out now

[Slaughter]

Fixed.

[MäxX]

Originally Posted by TheSlaughter

Fixed.

real nice, hopefully there will be more from you

Gonna check the stuff out and vote tomorrow

[klasnic]

Originally Posted by MäxX

real nice, hopefully there will be more from you

Gonna check the stuff out and vote tomorrow

Go Slaughter!! I've never heard of the pack either but I'll check it out and cast my vote too once I've seen her/them

[EDIT#1] I saw the date August '03 on the file when downloading which explains how I never heard of it. Long before my time

[EDIT#2] MäxX I just noticed your latest poll and had to comment :town:

EDIT#3 (MäxXStyle) Just wondering what you guys think about going back and closing the thread once a review's been posted. I was against the idea as it gives ppl a chance to cast their own vote and comment on it but there's a lot of spam going in there too which we feared. Comments? Suggestions?

[UTGirl]

Originally Posted by klasnic

.....
EDIT#3 (MäxXStyle) Just wondering what you guys think about going back and closing the thread once a review's been posted. I was against the idea as it gives ppl a chance to cast their own vote and comment on it but there's a lot of spam going in there too which we feared. Comments? Suggestions?

I wouldn`t lock it, I`m sure for the UC2-Skinpack will be some reviews and the polls are cool (MäxX will also be able to handle them in some time )

The OT-comments should simply be moved into the discussion thread by you admins.

[MäxX]

Better a wrong poll than a forgotten poll, I`m improving

I will manage the polls UTG I will ...sometimes.....maybe next year *lol*

I also wouldn`t lock the reviews, more diffrent reviews for one skin/model/whatever are better than more diffrent threads. I think this will get better sometimes, maybe we should make the other stickies unsticky (except vq and review list) and and make one (locked) sticky including the "rules", scoring sys and templates

EDIT: another option is to bann *lol: