Before I answer these questions I'd just like to state that in no way would I expect such a system to completely stop gun-related crime. There's still going to be very crazy people out there. But it will help.
I'm a bad guy so I'll keep my unmodded gun.
Which is the reason for new ammo. This kind of ammo will not fire in a conventional firearm, it will only fire in firearms that have the upgrade. It would take an act of congress to force gun shops to sell it over conventional ammo, but I bet it could be done.
I can't believe what a terrifyingly stupid idea this is.
Funny, I don't see you coming up with a better one.
At a time when freedoms in the United States are at a dismal all-time low and surveillance and control at an all-time high, you want to enable tracking
Damn right I do. People are clamoring for politicians to start gun control talks immediately, and what way you think they're going to pick? The easy way out, of course. The one where they ban all self-defense firearms. Then, only criminals will have these firearms.
That probably won't happen, but I'm worried that it could and a lot of people share my concern. It pays to be prepared. This would offer an alternative to completely shutting down gun ownership except for hunting purposes.
and remote disabling of firearms
Nope, just tracking, and only for the split-second when the firearm is discharged. I never said anything about remote disabling, don't know where you pulled that out of. Of course, we are against any kind of remote kill-switch. One of the conditions for an entity to use the system would be that they are not allowed to enable or add any sort of function that does this.
Who will manage such a system? Who watches the watchers?
That's not really my concern. We'll build the system and test it. If it catches on it would be up to government to decide who manages it. But most likely it would be managed by an appointed committee of some kind, or perhaps the NSA. There's also the option of allowing police to manage the system in their own territories (but the system would be nation-wide and publicly accessible, of course. Kind of like inmate and sex offender records are publicly accessible in many states.)
The system would be designed to be a deterrent against firearms-related crime, and to help authorities catch offenders faster than they can using forensics and questioning (which often turn up very little evidence.) Just imagine how fast you could catch a murderer if he was already tagged in a database that you could cross-reference with the time and location of the crime? That data would also be admissible evidence in court. This kind of system could make it that easy for the majority of gun-related crimes.
guns and ammo can be made all over the world. The black market's profit will sky rocket.
Obviously. I say let it; the U.S. and other territories can impose much tighter restrictions on black market arms and ammunition as a result. A crackdown on these is necessary anyways so why not let it be for this cause? The impact of such a system wouldn't be apparent right away, but I am willing to bet vast sums of money that you would see an incredible decrease in gun-related crime over a ten-year period as criminals start to run out of conventional ammo and sources of conventional ammo.