Clapton tho? :/ He's great, but I'd take Page or Hendrix over him any day.
Jimmy is definitely in the top 5.
Jimi is definitely in the top 10.
but at the end of the day, both of them generally adhere to a more narrow range of style and technique. so you can only listen to Hendrix and Zeppelin for so long before it all starts to sound the same. those driving psychedelic solos are great, but they're very egotistical and run together after awhile. I mean I get it, you can play the guitar well, let's hear some diversity.
also, neither of them is a very good singer.
Clapton however, is the most technically gifted all-around guitar player. others can be considered experts in their genre; though he's a true virtuoso of the instrument, same with Stevie.
Clapton will do his own thing, but even then it's not all about him or showing off how fast he can scale the neck. oftentimes it's about the story he tells, how well he can sing, how smooth he can play alongside the accompanying instrumentation in the song. I've never heard anyone play so crisp while maintaining speed and technicality, whether solo or ensemble, live or in studio.
he'll often appear with other "legends" from various/related styles of music. and he can play any style of music
better than the legend he's sharing the stage with.
/ 0.02