(From an avid video game from both HL/CS and Unreal worlds, whom is plagued with a 56k modem)
Over one year after preordering my copy, I was happy to see the box in my hands as the clerk gives me his thanks. I knew, going home, I would be unhappy with Steam's performance tonight. 6 (thats right, 6 ****ing hours aftering buying the game, thats 19 hours after the game as been released!) hours after installing, I was FINALLY able to play it on, what would be considered for this game, a low-end pc.
I must say, I enjoyed HL, I enjoyed its *FREE* mods such as Counter-Strike, TFC, Day of Defeat, Firearms, etc. This game however, was not worth its wait and hype. Is it a good game? Sure. Will it kill any other game? No.
I actually heard sounds, like steam, that were the exact sounds from the original game. 5 years of development, and obviously not any of that was spent to heavily in the audio department. Getting passed the crackled sound coming out of my 5.1 speakers (performance issues and/or the fact steam fragmented all my gam files play in part here, both should have been addressed by the developers anyhow), I found myself noticing the lackluster polycount in much of the levels. Obviously, this game is meant for higher-end systems that, through bump maping and other techniquies, are able to think there are more polys being drawn then there is. For us lower end saps, I can say the textures are alright at least. Overall its a great achivement, but not equal to its hype.
Pirating is bad. No argument there by anyone I'm sure... But there are more complex issues surrounding pirating: those who pirate, will they actually buy the game if copy-protections worked 100%? Does copy-protection turn off potentional buyers? Here's my theory about copy-protection: If legit users can't play the game because of copy protection, but non-legit users can through cracks/etc., the copy-protection has not only failed, but has caused a loss in revenue and thus is bad. Activation via steam will cause a lot of people to not buy HL2, I'm positive. Some will get mad at valve's unpreparedness (come on, five years of development and they haven't the foresight this would occcur?!), some will think the game is broken, and others will just not have the internet.
Dunno how copy-protection ties into the belief that jews are the cause of everythign and should be exterminated, but I do know this. If you don't like copy protection how it is, don't buy the game. If you can deal with it. Buy it. If you think its not annoying enough, pirate the game.