PDA

View Full Version : Scoring Schema / Template / Welcome Thread


SaD
29th Jul 2005, 12:10 PM
Welcome to our Review-section.

A little note from me .

Please be civil .If you review a first attempt of skinning , don´t be so harsh.
Constructive critic is way better.
Try to give your Review a scheme , like MäxX (http://forums.beyondunreal.com/showthread.php?t=162206) did.

Have fun reading or writing some reviews.

Edit:
Please don´t fill the reviews with spam.We like to have open review-threads, so everyone can vote.
Spam/Offtopic will be deleted immediatly .

klasnic
1st Aug 2005, 02:10 PM
Hey all I've just gone by some of the reviews here (and the way they're laid out), so have thrown together this template (of sorts) for general use...

As a heading if we could use e.g., UT2004 - MODEL/SKIN - GAME MODEL (if applicable) Hide - FireDrake v1.0

Skin/Model Name:
UT(99/2k3/2k4):
System Requirements: (if applicable)
Author(s): Add Homepage / SkinCity Author Link
Download: Add SkinCity Link If Possible

Screenshot:

Model: (Existing Game/Modified Game/Original)
Animation: (does it use default animations or new - if applicable)
Voice: (does it come with a custom voice - where applicable)
Other: (for anything not mentioned above e.g., species, karma, customization of any sort)

Support (SP/MP/Both):
Support (Team Colours) (None/2/4):
Known Issues:
Additional Info (if applicable):

REVIEW

[Opening comments here]

The Good:

[Good parts here]

The Bad:

[Not-so-good parts here]

The Bottom Line:

[Final comments and recommendation(s) here]

TOTAL SCORE (0-10/10 or 0-100/100%)

-----

[EDIT#1] May edit this as we go along and think of new things :)
[EDIT#2] Added a custom animation field, etc.
[EDIT#3] Changed the body of the review to Starry Might's style.

klasnic
4th Aug 2005, 11:01 PM
The reviews are scored like this (thanks UTGirl);

0 - One Of The Worst Ever
1 - Serious Data Crap
2 - Bad Quality
3 - There's Better
4 - Some People Might Like It
5 - Average
6 - Good (but not a keeper)
7 - Very Good (definitely a keeper)
8 - Excellent (you'll use this for a long time to come)
9 - Perfect (SaDaGe!!)
10 - H0LY SH1T!!

Any changes necessary? Post in discussion thread please :2thumb:

daloonie
6th Aug 2005, 03:32 PM
A "source code" for this template could be easy to swing around so I'll take the oppertunity to post it here. This will in some way help reviewers a bit since they only have to copy paste this and fill in the blanks.
Skin/Model Name:[/b*]
[b]UT(99/2k3/2k4):[/b*]
[b]System Requirements:[/b*]
[b]Author(s):[/b*]
[b]Download:[/b*][url][/url*]

[b]Screenshot:[/b*][img=][url][/url*][/img*] or [screenshot][/screenshot*] or [img][/img*]

[b]Model:[/b*]
[b]Animation:[/b*]
[b]Voice:[/b*]
[b]Other:[/b*]

[b]Support (SP/MP/Both):[/b*]
[b]Support (Team Colours) (None/2/4):[/b*]
[b]Known Issues:[/b*]
[b]Additional Info (if applicable):[/b*]

[b]REVIEW[/b*]

[Opening comments here]

The Good:

[Good parts here]

The Bad:

[Not-so-good parts here]

The Bottom Line:

[Final comments and recommendation(s) here]

[b]TOTAL SCORE[/b*] (0-10/10 or 0-100/100%)

Just remove the *'s and fill it out. Simple as that

EDIT:: I cleaned out this thread to keep it clean. Every suggestion can be posted and after consideration/and action taken it will initially be deleted to keep it as clean as possible.





[b]Now remember to post a poll with it. So people can judge the skin themselves to get a broader spectrum of oppinions.
If you forget it contact a moderator and we can call it a "MxX". We'll delete it so you can repost it with a poll. ASAP.